Does Dan Savage, of the Village Voice's Savage Love owe Katie a Hitachi Magic Wand?

He promised her one by email but then he forgot to bring it to a first meeting at a bookstore where he was giving a reading. He contends she acted rudely and boorishly when he didn't have her gift with him.. He is using this as grounds to nullify his offering of a sex toy gift.

She has put up a web site with her side of the story:MagicWand4Katie.com, and Dan has asked several female sex toy store retailers to visit and email both of them and make a decision.

I say Dan should give her the wand and I will volunteer to give Katie any helping hand I can. Besides, Dan is stupid about the Iraq war as well.